Sky and Sol vs Wild Gold Tallow: An Honest Colostrum Comparison

Written by Jamie, co-founder of Wild Gold Tallow. Jamie left Los Angeles for a farm outside Asheville, North Carolina to raise the family's own food, raw milk, and first colostrum, and now obsesses over where every ingredient comes from.

If you are weighing Sky and Sol vs Wild Gold Tallow, you have probably already figured out something most shoppers miss: colostrum belongs in skincare, not just in a supplement jar. Both brands use it, which puts them ahead of nearly everyone else in the tallow world. This is an honest, side-by-side look at how the two lines actually differ, so you can pick the one that fits your skin. We make one of them, so I will be upfront about that and keep the facts fair.

Sky and Sol is a real brand doing real work in the ancestral skincare space, and we are not here to knock them. We just build our balm on a different philosophy, and those differences are worth understanding before you spend your money.

Sky and Sol vs Wild Gold Tallow at a glance

Here is the honest breakdown, ingredient by ingredient. Both use grass-fed tallow and both use colostrum. After that, the two formulas head in different directions.

• Colostrum grade: Sky and Sol lists colostrum in its Everything Cream but does not specify a grade or the timing of the milking. We use rare first colostrum, the milking taken within about six hours of birth, which is the most nutrient-dense form.
• Ingredient count: Sky and Sol's Everything Cream blends grass-fed tallow, mango butter, propolis, jojoba oil, colostrum, and beeswax. Ours is three ingredients: grass-fed tallow, first colostrum, and USA emu oil.
• Base: Several Sky and Sol products are water-based creams. Ours is a waterless balm, so nothing is padded out with water.
• Carrier oil: They use jojoba oil. We use USA-certified emu oil, which penetrates deeper than common plant oils and helps carry the colostrum nutrients down with it.
• Beeswax: Their creams include beeswax. We leave it out to keep the balm simple and fast-absorbing.
• Emu oil: Sky and Sol does not use emu oil. We do.

Where Sky and Sol is a good choice

Credit where it is due. If you like a richer, more traditional cream with botanicals, Sky and Sol delivers that. Ingredients like mango butter and propolis give their Everything Cream a fuller, more classic-lotion feel, and their range is broad, with tallow soaps, masks, and sunscreen alongside the creams. Some people simply prefer a water-based cream texture over a balm. If you want a whole botanical cream rather than a stripped-down balm, they are a solid, honest pick.

Where Wild Gold Tallow differentiates

Our whole idea is close to the opposite of an everything cream. We cut the formula down to the three ingredients we think actually matter for skin, then spend the savings on their quality. Rare first colostrum. USA-certified emu oil. 100% grass-fed and finished tallow. Nothing else, no water, no beeswax, no plant butters, no fragrance in the unscented.

The three work together on purpose. Tallow builds a skin-compatible base. Emu oil carries the nutrients deeper than jojoba can. First colostrum brings the growth factors, lactoferrin, and peptides that support fresh, healthy-looking skin. Because there is no water to pad it out, a little goes a long way.

"Love this tallow with emu oil and colostrum! Haven't found this combination anywhere!" — Lynn

The colostrum is personal for us. When we started, we already had the answer on our own farm outside Asheville. A friend named Rachel, who makes tallow skincare, suggested we blend our fresh first colostrum into a tallow base. That collaboration became the balm we now use on our own family every day.

Which one should you choose?

It really comes down to what you want on your skin. If you like a fuller botanical cream and enjoy ingredients like mango butter and propolis, Sky and Sol is a fair choice. If you want a minimalist, waterless balm built around a specified first colostrum grade plus USA emu oil, that is exactly what we make. You can compare the whole range in our colostrum skincare collection, and the one we reach for daily is the Colostrum Tallow Balm. For a deeper look at why the colostrum grade matters so much, read our guide to the best colostrum skincare.

Frequently asked questions

Does Sky and Sol use first colostrum?

Sky and Sol lists colostrum in its Everything Cream but does not specify a grade or the timing of the milking, so we cannot confirm it is first colostrum. Wild Gold Tallow uses rare first colostrum, the milking taken within about six hours of birth.

Is Wild Gold Tallow a good Sky and Sol alternative?

If you want a minimalist, waterless balm built around first colostrum and USA emu oil rather than a multi-ingredient botanical cream, Wild Gold Tallow is a natural alternative. If you prefer a richer cream with mango butter and propolis, Sky and Sol may suit you better.

What is the main difference between Sky and Sol and Wild Gold Tallow?

Both use grass-fed tallow and colostrum. Sky and Sol's Everything Cream is a multi-ingredient formula with mango butter, propolis, jojoba oil, and beeswax. Wild Gold Tallow is a three-ingredient waterless balm of grass-fed tallow, first colostrum, and USA emu oil, and it specifies the colostrum grade.

Do both brands use grass-fed tallow?

Yes. Both build their products on grass-fed beef tallow. The differences are in the other ingredients, the colostrum grade, and whether emu oil is used.

The bottom line on Sky and Sol vs Wild Gold Tallow

Both brands understood something early that most of the industry still misses, which is that colostrum has a real place in skincare. From there it is a choice between two philosophies: a fuller botanical cream, or a three-ingredient balm that names its colostrum grade and adds USA emu oil. We are biased toward simple, but both are honest products. If the minimalist route appeals to you, ours lives in the colostrum skincare collection. You might also like our other honest head-to-heads, including Hearth and Homestead vs Wild Gold Tallow and Primally Pure vs Wild Gold Tallow, plus emu oil vs tallow for skin.

These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.